www.flickr.com

Defeats the point, doesn’t it?

Schools are having problems with parents doing their childrens’ homework, and are having to warn parents off. Some schools are making the kids do their assignments in class time to make sure it is actually their own work.

Sort of defeats the point of homework doesn’t it? I know parents hand hold their children, but this is over the top. How are they going to actually learn anything, if mum or dad does their work for them? Might get some better marks in the short term, but ultimately the kids have to stand on their own efforts. What, is mum or dad going to do their university assignments for them, or if they do that, going to get a job and do it for them?

The worry for educators, as well as children not learning by their own efforts, is potential psychological damage over-zealous parents are doing, robbing their self-esteem, undermining self confidence, causing kids to feel they can never be good enough.

“The message parents send when they do the work for their kids is, ‘You can’t do it well enough, I’ll do it for you,’ ” said Elbie Van Coller, a school counsellor on the North Shore. “It’s producing some very anxious children.”

According to psychologist Madeline Levine, parents are increasingly worried about their children’s future and exert, however subtly, pressure to excel. The more scared the parents, the more controlling they become. Many end up giving more than a helping hand in homework to ensure their child’s mark is high enough.

“While demands for outstanding academic or extracurricular performance are very high, expectations about family responsibilities are amazingly low,” Dr Levine said. “This kind of imbalance in expectations results in kids who regularly expect others to ‘take up the slack’, rather than learning how to prioritise tasks or how to manage time.”

The biggest problem I have with my kids’ homework is that I’ve forgotten how to do half the stuff, so I’m not that much use. As for me doing their work ….ROFLMAO!!!!!

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Sphinn
  • Facebook

  1. 5 Responses to “Defeats the point, doesn’t it?”

  2. It’s terrible, but I know someone who does all of their childrens homework.

    They’ll complain about how much work they have to do as well as all the assignments, and will then come in and brag at the mark they got.

    The main reason appears to be so that they’ll get a decent UAI, but I fail to see how that will an iota of difference when/if they get to uni as they never went themselves…

    By Enny on Sep 23, 2006

  3. I can understand parents wanting to help their children, but doing all of the homework really does defeat the purpose, as you said.

    I used to tutor young children in EFL (English as a Foreign Language) and some mothers would sit there in the room and whisper the answers to their kids right in front of me! What was the point of doing that???

    By TheBizofKnowledge on Sep 23, 2006

  4. Wow. That’s crazy!

    I can’t imagine doing my kids homework — although I do get irritated at the volume of homework some teachers assign.

    It’s one thing to do a large project with lots of different components, its quite another to assign 50 or 100 redundant problems!

    tp

    By TerraPraeta on Sep 25, 2006

  5. Recently, MissB had an energy assignment (build a model out of recycling material). She came up with the design, and picked what would look best, etc. We helped put it together, and sent her off to school. MrsB reported that some of the kids in here class (Yr 3/4) looked like their work was almost professional jobs!

    By Boysenberry on Sep 25, 2006

  6. I don’t do my daughters homework but I help her with it a lot. She gets so much sometimes that if I didn’t she’d be spending most of her spare time doing it.

    Homework shits me, I think that 6 hours a day at school is enough without making them work after school as well.

    By Jo on Sep 26, 2006

Post a Comment

Readers who viewed this page, also viewed:

  • N/A